Book Bhagavata
Keshava Swami WebsiteFollow @keshavaswamiSupport this work
  • Welcome to Book Bhagavata Online!
  • Credits
  • Contents
  • The Inspiration
  • Acknowledgements
  • Family Tree
  • Introduction
    • Life's Constant Companion
    • Srimad-Bhagavatam Travels West
    • The Greatest Gift
    • Hidden Gems
    • Book Bhagavata
  • CANTO 01
    • S.L.A.P
      • S - Srimad-Bhagavatam (1-6)
        • Glorious Bhagavatam
        • Essential Truths of Bhagavatam (Six Questions)
        • The Goal of Bhagavatam (Sri Krishna)
        • History of Bhagavatam (Four Questions)
        • Compilation of Bhagavatam
        • Ripened fruit
          • The Narrations of Srimad-Bhagavatam
      • L - Love (7-11)
        • The Love of Arjuna
        • The Love of Uttara
        • The Love of Kunti
        • The Love of Bhismadeva
        • The Love of Hastinapura’s Residents (Separation)
        • The Love of Dwaraka’s Residents (Union)
        • Pure Love
          • Rasa Theology
          • Our Relationship with Krishna
      • A - Attaining the Absolute (12-15)
        • Pariksit’s Birth (and Eventual Departure)
        • Dhritarastra Departs
        • Krishna Departs
        • Kunti, Pandavas, Vidura, Draupadi and Subhadra Depart
        • The Final Lesson
          • An Inconvenient Truth?
          • Back to Godhead
      • P - Pariksit Punished (16-19)
        • Pariksit’s Rule
        • Pariksit and Kali
        • Pariksit Cursed
        • Pariksit Retires and Sukadeva Enters
        • Navigating Life
  • Canto 02
    • C.U.T
      • C - Connect (1-3)
        • Disconnect to Connect
        • Connection Processes
        • Bhakti: The Ultimate Connection
        • Live Connection
          • The Nature of God
          • Investing in a Relationship
      • U - Universal Creation (4-7)
        • Process of Universal Creation
        • Purusa Sukta and the Universal Form
        • Universal Incarnations
        • The Beginning
          • Why is the Universe Created?
          • When is the Universe Created?
          • Importance of Creation
      • T - Total Theology (8-10)
        • Theological Enquiries
        • Total Theology in Four Verses
        • Total Theology in Ten Subjects
        • Prelude to Canto 3 (Vidura)
        • Ten Truths
          • Four Verses
          • Ten Topics
  • Canto 03
    • S.A.V.E.S
      • S - Stories of the Supreme (1-4)
        • Vidura’s Pilgrimage
        • Stories in Vrindavana
        • Stories Outside of Vrindavana
        • Story of Krishna’s Disappearance
        • Story Time
          • Why are stories so powerful?
          • The Good Listener
      • A - Assembly and Activation (5-12)
        • Assembly and Activation
        • Clarification
        • Brahma's Empowerment
        • Brahma's Creation
        • Vedic Time
        • Activation of Progeny
        • Creative Ideas
          • Big Bang, Big Doubt
          • Live Options
      • V - Varahadeva (13-19)
        • Appearance of Varahadeva
        • Flashback - Birth of the Demons
        • Further Flashback - Past Lives of the Demons
        • Varahadeva Kills Hiranyaksa
        • Avatara
          • One but Different
          • Divine Play
      • E - Expanding Entities (20-24)
        • Different Entities Created
        • Devahuti and Kardama Muni
        • Devahuti Gives Birth and Kardama Departs
        • The Life Cycle
          • Orders of Life
          • Occupations in Life
          • Varieties of Varnasrama
      • S - Sankya-yoga (25-33)
        • Defining Sankhya-yoga
        • Material Nature
        • Astanga-yoga
        • Bhakti-yoga
        • Worldly Entanglement (Samsara)
        • Devahuti’s Prayers and Kapila’s Renunciation
        • Detached Attachment
          • Monkey Business
          • Detach to Attach
  • CANTO 04
    • S.K.I.P
      • S – Siva and Sati (1-7)
        • Genealogy of Manu’s Daughters
        • Siva Cursed
        • Sati’s Desire, Decision, Downfall and Death
        • Siva Creates Virabhadra
        • Siva Pacified and Daksa Reinstated
        • Bankruptcy
          • Get Rich Quick
          • Mediate Before You Meditate
      • K - Kingly Desires (8-12)
        • Dhruva’s Kingly Desire
        • Dhruva’s Reward
        • Dhruva’s Fight
        • Dhruva’s Perfection
        • Determination
          • Take a Risk
          • External Support and Internal Mindset
      • I - Ideal Leadership (13-23)
        • Anga’s Detachment
        • Vena Killed
        • Prthu’s Appearance
        • Prthu and Mother Earth
        • Prthu’s Horse Sacrifices
        • Ideal Leadership
        • Prthu’s Perfection
        • Leadership
          • Selfless
          • Spiritual
          • Strong
      • P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
        • Pracetas Hear Rudra-Gita
        • Puranjana Story
        • Pracinabarhisat Attains Perfection
        • Pracetas Rule
        • Priyavrata – Elder Son of Manu
        • Root of Devotion
          • The Beginning
          • Why is this Important?
          • Proofreaders of Devotion
  • CANTO 05
    • R.E.A.P
      • R - Rishabhadeva (1-6)
        • Priyavrata’s Marriage
        • Agnidhra’s Family Life
        • Rishabhadeva’s Appearance
        • Rishabhadeva’s Qualities
        • Rishabhadeva’s Teachings and Departure
        • Essential Instructions
          • Knowledge and Devotion
      • E - Emperor to Deer (7-15)
        • 1st Life – Emperor Bharata
        • 2nd Life - Emperor to Deer
        • 3rd Life - Deer to Jada Bharata
        • Jada Bharata instructs Rahugana
        • Bharata’s Descendants
        • Attention!
          • Bloop
          • Casual Causes Casualty
          • Deepening our Devotion
      • A - Astronomical Avataras (16-19)
        • Jambudvipa
        • Descent of the Ganges
        • Astronomical Avataras
        • Worldview
          • Path of Karma – AT the World
          • Path of Jnana – AWAY from the World
          • Path of Bhakti – BEYOND the World
      • P - Planetary Systems (20-26)
        • Six Islands
        • Movements of the Sun
        • Orbits of the Planets and Sisumara
        • Subterranean Heavens
        • Lord Anantadeva
        • Hellish Planets
        • Universal Map
          • Higher Planets
          • Middle Planets
          • Lower Planets (Subterranean Heavens)
          • Lower Planets (Hells)
  • CANTO 06
    • E.P.I.C
      • E - Escaping Hell (1-3)
        • Ultimate Atonement
        • Ajamila’s History
        • Ajamila’s Second Chance
        • Yamaraja’s Explanation
          • The Holy Name
          • The Nature of the Holy Name
          • The Chanting of the Holy Name
          • The Experience of the Holy Name
          • The Potential of the Holy Name
      • P - Prajapati Daksa (4-6)
        • Prajapati Daksa’s Birth and Prayers
        • Daksa Frustrated and Narada Cursed
        • Prajapati Daksa’s Daughters
        • Real Renunciates
          • Create Doubt
          • Create Faith
          • Giving Narayana
      • I - Indra and Vritrasura (7-13)
        • Indra, Brhaspati and Narayana Kavaca
        • Indra Kills Visvarupa
        • Indra’s Enemy, Vritrasura
        • Dadhici’s Sacrifice
        • The Great Fight
        • Indra Kills Vritrasura
        • Upside Down
          • Identifying Pure Devotion
          • Testing Pure Devotion
      • C - Chitraketu (14-19)
        • Chitraketu’s Lamentation
        • Chitraketu Enlightened
        • Chitraketu Cursed
        • Diti, Indra and the Maruts
        • River of Names
          • Attention vs Attachment
          • Transcendental Affection
  • CANTO 07
    • O.P.E.N
      • O - Oppressive Ogre (1-4)
        • Impartiality of God
        • Jaya and Vijaya
        • Hiranyakasipu - Aggrieved but Philosophical
        • Overcoming Death
        • Oppressive Ogre
        • Divine and Demoniac
          • Demoniac Philosophy
          • Demoniac Mentality
          • Demoniac Activity
          • Demoniac Destiny
          • Conquering the Demon Within
      • P - Prahlada Maharaja (5-7)
        • Prahlada's Education
        • Prahlada Tortured
        • Prahlada's Preaching
        • Prahlada's Upbringing
        • Nine Process
          • Examples of Perfection
          • Two Divisions
          • The Most Important
          • Eighty-one Varieties of Devotional Service
      • E - Enraged Entrance (8-10)
        • Enraged Entrance
        • Enraged Lord is Pacified
        • Prahlada Benedicted and Coronated
        • Siva as Tripurari
        • See Krishna
          • Utilising Time
      • N - Narada's Instructions (11-15)
        • Civilised Humans
        • Brahmacarya / Vanaprastha
        • Sannyasa
        • Grhasta
        • Levels of Brahmanas
        • Narada's History
        • Finding Dharma
          • Self Discovery
  • CANTO 08
    • G.O.L.D
      • G - Gajendra (1-4)
        • Different Manus
        • Gajendra's Crisis
        • Gajendra's Prayers
        • Gajendra's Past Life
        • Power of Prayer
          • What to Pray for?
          • The Key Ingredient
          • Types of Prayers
          • Keep Calm: Krishna will come
      • O - Ocean of Milk (5-12)
        • Prayers at the Milk Ocean
        • Churning the Milk Ocean
        • The Nectar and Mohini-Murti
        • Demigods and Demons Fight
        • Siva and Mohini-Murti
        • Land of the Gods
          • God (Bhagavan)
          • Incarnations (Avatara)
          • Demigods (Devata)
          • Why do People Worship Demigods?
          • Why is Demigod Worship Unintelligent?
          • Vedic, Vaisnava and Gaudiya
      • L - Leaders of Society (13-15)
        • Manus 7-14
        • Leadership Duties
        • Laws of Mankind
          • Manu Samhita
          • Time, Place and Circumstance
          • Guru, Sadhu and Sastra
          • Extremes
      • D - Dwarf Incarnation (15-24)
        • Bali's Fightback
        • Aditi and the Dwarf Incarnation
        • Donation for the Dwarf
        • The Third Step
        • Prahlada's Reassurance and Demigods Reinstated
        • Matsya Avatara
        • Surrender
          • Types of Surrender
          • Surrender - Natural but Gradual
          • Sustainable Surrender
  • Canto 09
    • D.R.A.G
      • D – Durvasa and Ambarish (1-5)
        • Dynasty of Vaivasvata Manu
        • Durvasa Offends Ambarish
        • Durvasa Forgiven
        • Power and Purity
          • Advisors
          • Knowledge
          • Absorption
          • Character
          • Responsibility
          • Succession
      • R – Ramacandra (6-13)
        • Saubhari Muni
        • Other Descendants
        • Ramacandra’s Pastimes
        • Ramacandra’s Reign
        • Dynasties of Iksvaku
        • Purusottama
          • Being Exemplary
          • Banishing Sita
      • A – Axe-Wielding Avatara (14-16)
        • Pururava and Urvasi
        • Avatara Annihilates Administrators
        • Heavy Handed
          • Play Fight
          • Avoiding Confrontation
          • The Non-Violent Incarnation
      • G – God’s Gotra (17-24)
        • Yayati and Devayani
        • Bharata and Rantideva
        • Bhismadeva and Pandavas
        • Yayati’s Dynasty
        • God from Goloka: Sri Krishna
        • Genealogy
          • Soma and Surya
          • Two Disciplic Successions
          • Our Disciplic Line
  • Canto 10 (Part 1)
    • B.A.B.Y
      • B – Birth (1-5)
        • Preparation
        • The Omen
        • Balarama Transferred and Garbha-Stuti
        • Baby Krishna’s Appearance
        • Kamsa’s Frustration
        • Nanda and Vasudeva Meet
        • Krishna’s Birth
          • An Interesting Detail
          • Krishna Appearing in Our Life
      • A – Attacking Asuras and Astonishing Activities (6-14)
        • Attacking Asuras
        • Astonishing Activities
        • Attacking More Asuras
        • Brahma’s Illusion
        • Demons and Anarthas
          • The Process of Anartha-Nivrtti
      • B – Boyhood (15-28)
        • Defeating More Demons
        • Krishna and the Ladies of Vrindavana
        • Lifting Govardhana Hill
        • Nanda Rescued
        • The Real World
          • Manifestations of Vrindavana
          • Krishna as the Centre
          • Stages of Krishna’s Life
          • History of Vrindavana
      • Y – Youthood (29-40)
        • Rasa Pancadhyaya
        • More Demons Killed
        • Akrura’s Mission
        • A God that Dances
          • God vs Krishna
  • Canto 10 (Part 2)
    • M.A.D
      • M – Mathura-Lila (41-51)
        • Kamsa Killed
        • Gurukula
        • Uddhava in Vrindavana / Akrura in Hastinapura
        • Dwaraka Established
        • Cry for Krishna
          • Separation for a Sadhaka
          • The Mood of Sri Chaitanya
      • A – Astonishing Rule (52-70)
        • Rana-Chor Lila
        • Rukmini and Krishna
        • History of Pradyumna
        • The Syamantaka Jewel
        • Marrying Princesses
        • Rukmini Teased and Rukmi Killed
        • Banasura Defeated
        • Nriga Delivered
        • Balarama in Vrindavana
        • Killing More Demons
        • Samba’s Marriage
        • Dwaraka Palaces
        • Dhama Comparison
          • The Lost City
          • Spiritual Hubs
          • Habits of Successful Pilgrims
          • The Dwaraka Queens hear Srimad-Bhagavatam
      • D – Demons, Devotees and Divinity (71-90)
        • Rajasuya, Jarasandha and Sisupala
        • Salva, Dantavakra and Viduranath Slayed
        • Balarama kills Romaharsana and Balvala
        • Sudama Vipra
        • Kuruksetra Meeting
        • Krishna Blesses His Devotees
        • Krishna’s Supremacy
        • Atheism
          • The Mood of the Spiritual World
  • CANTO 11
    • S.U.M
      • S - Sage’s Teachings (1-6)
        • Yadu’s Cursed
        • Sages’ Teachings
        • Yadus Travel to Prabhasa
          • Pure Bhakti
          • Defining Suddha-Bhakti
          • Essential Qualities (svarupa-laksana)
          • Marginal Qualities (tatastha-laksana)
          • Happiness of Service
      • U - Uddhava-gita (7-29)
        • Twenty-Four Gurus
        • Entanglement, Liberation and Pure Love
        • Topmost Yoga System
        • Varnasrama
        • Knowledge to Bhakti
        • Understanding Material Nature
        • Avanti Brahmana and Bhiksu-Gita
        • Pururava – Aila-Gita
        • Deity Worship and Bhakti-Yoga
          • Uddhava-Gita
          • Before and After the Uddhava-Gita
          • Essential Similarities
      • M - Mausala-lila (30-31)
        • Disappearance of Yadus
        • Disappearance of Krishna
          • Divine Play
          • Why did Krishna end His pastimes?
          • Why didn’t Krishna remain with His devotees on earth?
          • Why did Krishna depart in a seemingly mundane way?
          • Why did Krishna leave a body behind?
          • Multidimensional Pastimes
          • Entering the Pastimes
  • CANTO 12
    • N.A.M.E
      • N - Nasty Age (1-3)
        • Nasty Kings
        • Nasty Yuga
        • Evolution of Theism
          • Bringing Back the Essence
      • A - Annihilation (4-7)
        • Types of Annihilation
        • Annihilation of Pariksit’s Body
        • Vedic Literature
        • Ego Death
          • Destructive Enlightenment
          • Impact of Knowledge
      • M - Markendeya Rishi (8-10)
        • Markandeya’s Austerity
        • Markandeya’s Vision of Maya
        • Conspiracy 108
          • How Maya Enters
          • Tricks of Maya
      • E - Ending The Epic (11-13)
        • Ending Glorification
        • Read and Relish
          • Daily Bath
          • Read or Relish?
  • Appendix
    • Bibliography
    • The Author
    • Wisdom That Breathes
    • Read the Srimad-Bhagavatam Online
    • Support this work
Powered by GitBook
On this page
  1. CANTO 04
  2. S.K.I.P
  3. P – Pracinabarhisat, Pracetas and Puranjana (24-31)
  4. Root of Devotion

The Beginning

PreviousRoot of DevotionNextWhy is this Important?

Last updated 5 months ago

In Madhurya Kadambini, Visvanatha Chakravarti Thakura scientifically analyses the soul’s spiritual journey. He systematically delineates a sequence of eight stages that a sincere and serious practitioner will progress through before arriving at the ultimate goal, pure love of God (prema). Before describing the journey, Visvanatha Chakravarti spends considerable time discussing how one begins that spiritual journey.

Our attraction for devotional activities (which is carried from previous lives) impels us towards further execution of those devotional activities in this life. That subsequent execution further increases one’s attraction. But where does the initial attraction come from? During our material sojourn, what is the turning point at which one begins cultivating their relationship with God? How is that seed of bhakti implanted within the heart?

Visvanatha Chakravarti Thakura explores a variety of options. Some may posit that the cause of bhakti is good fortune. Such an explanation is inconclusive, since the question remains as to how that good fortune arises. Others may propose that the cause of bhakti is good karma and pious activity. This is unacceptable since piety is still a material activity, and how could something material be the cause of something divinely spiritual? Some may posit that Krishna is the cause of bhakti. But then we face another problem since Krishna says “I envy no one, nor am I partial to anyone. I am equal to all.” (). With that in mind, why would He bestow good fortune on some and not others?

In a deeply realised and illuminating fashion, Visvanatha Chakravarti Thakura reveals that the journey to pure love ultimately begins when one contacts a devotee of Krishna: “The root cause of devotional service to Lord Krishna is association with advanced devotees. Even when one’s dormant love for Krishna awakens, association with devotees is still most essential.” ()

Since Vaisnavas have bhakti implanted within their hearts, they are impelled and equipped to give it to others, and in this way instigate the spiritual journey of another. Thus, in the deepest sense, bhakti is the cause of bhakti. Although this analysis may seem deeply philosophical, it’s incredibly practical and simple. We have all experienced that even ordinary love can’t be bought, forced, or manufactured. It is the product of an individual’s free will and desire. Only love creates love, and only divine love creates divine love. So, if we want divine love, we must encounter someone who has it. If we are fortunate to meet such a person, and receptive enough to accept that divine gift, our spiritual journey begins.

BG 9.29
CC Madhya 22.83